PDA

View Full Version : And people wonder why racial profiling exists


Adam_Schwartz
December 14, 2006, @ 12:47 PM
I wonder when CAIR will step in and say this guy's civil rights were violated?

Authorities Probe Foreign Student Seeking Commercial Truck-Driving HAZMAT License

NEW YORK — Mohammed Yusef Mullawala wanted a license to transport hazardous materials and to learn how to drive commercial tractor trailers. There was nothing unusual about that, until he told his teacher that he only wanted to learn how to drive forward, and he wanted to learn fast.

That was enough to raise a red flag with Darleen Crawford, president of the Nationwide Tractor Trailer Driving School in Smithfield, R.I., where Mullawala took driving classes.

Federal and state authorities are investigating why Mullawala was seeking a commercial trucking license after his behavior raised flags at the Rhode Island driving school. Crawford said he was also insistent on taking the test necessary to earn a license to transport hazardous materials.

Mullawala, a 28-year-old citizen of India who is of Pakistani descent, is now in federal custody in Massachusetts on immigration violation charges.

"We are still digging into his background, digging into where he lived in Rhode Island, New York and New Jersey," Major Steven O'Donnell with the Rhode Island State Police told FOXNews.com on Wednesday. "A lot of still doesn't make any sense, why he would be doing what he was doing."

Crawford said Mullawala came to the school with a Rhode Island driver's license inquiring how to obtain a commercial driver's license within a month. It normally takes around eight weeks for a student to go through all of the required courses before he or she obtains a permit, she said.

"We've been doing this for quite a long time and a lot of things just didn't add up," Crawford said.

Crawford started documenting suspicious activity: Mullawala lived in New York City but traveled to Rhode Island for the driving classes; he missed his first day of classes; and he was very insistent on getting his hazardous material transport license.

But the fact that he only seemed interested in driving forward was the most concerning.

"We tell them from Day One, 'you will be backing up,' 'you'll be backing up every single day,'" Crawford said, adding that it normally takes two to three weeks of practice backing up before drivers get road permits and learn how to drive forward, among other things.

The situation was reminiscent of when some of the Sept. 11, 2001, hijackers told their flight-school instructor they were only interested in how to fly planes at certain altitudes, not so much how to land or take off.

"He was just really pushing to get out of here," Crawford said. "I've been doing this for 30 years so you just sort of know when something doesn't feel right."

After Mullawala took two classes, Crawford contacted Highway Watch, which had conducted an anti-terrorism and safety program at her school.

Jim Sutton, director of the Highway Watch's Information Sharing and Analysis Center, said it was the "calibrated judgment" of his five-person staff of former military, national intelligence and security officers that caused them to pass Mullawala's information on to federal authorities.

"Over a period of time, you learn that certain indicators are very valid, that they just stand out," Sutton said. "They're so anomalous to the norm that you say to yourself, 'there is something here. We need to pursue, we need to follow up.'"

In Mullawala's case, Sutton said, "there was a sense of urgency he had in finishing the course."

"Well, you don't learn those type of mechanical skills very fast," he added.

The ISAC contacted the Department of Homeland Security, which contacted Rhode Island state police.

A joint investigation was then launched by investigators from the Rhode Island State Fusion Center, the FBI's Joint Terrorism Task Force (JTTF) in Rhode Island, New York and New Jersey and the Bureau of Immigration and Customs Enforcement.

Investigators learned that when Mullawala obtained his driver's license from the Rhode Island Registry of Motor Vehicles, he gave a false statement indicating he was a Rhode Island resident. ICE then determined he was a citizen of India and in the United States on an expired temporary student visa.

On Tuesday, Mullawala went to state police headquarters thinking he was responding to another matter. He was then apprehended and turned over to ICE.

He's being held in the federal Suffolk County detention center in Boston until his immigration hearing in Boston, which is expected to be sometime within the next few weeks. He will be charged with overstaying his visa and is facing possible deportation back to India.

O'Donnell said his department, as well as the New York and New Jersey JTTFs, are investigating Mullawala's background and the residences he had in those three states.

Authorities have not yet turned up the names of any other specific individuals Mullawala may have been conspiring with.

"He didn't have family, he did have friends," O'Donnell said, adding that authorities are trying to track down people Mullawala was associated with in New York, where his most recent address is located.

That address is 161 84th Road in Jamaica, Queens, according to Rhode Island police. He also has a residence on Carpenter Street in Providence, R.I., which he apparently hasn't lived at since 2003.

Police are also studying a computer taken from one of Mullawala's residence, O'Donnell said, adding that the man apparently was a computer expert. They will look at his e-mails, as well as any Web sites he frequented. Any potential overseas connections will be handled by the FBI and DHS, O'Donnell said, although none have yet turned up.

An official at the New York JTTF office contacted by FOXNews.com said he could not comment on the status of this or any ongoing investigation.

More than 500,000 transportation workers — including school-bus drivers to mass transit workers — call in tips as part of the Highway Watch program, said spokesman John Willard. The Highway Watch ISAC vets the calls to determine which ones are substantial enough to pass on to federal authorities.

"We get a few hundred [calls] a month," Willard said. "They range from anything from 'there's a guy in his car on the side of a road' ... to 'I'm witnessing a crime' ... to 'there's this person who seems suspicious.'"

He added: "We've gotten a few of those we believe have led to very credible investigations."

The Highway Watch ISAC was first established by DHS in March of 2004. The original Highway Watch was set up in 1998 as a safety program and run by the American Trucking Association up until 2004. It added an anti-terrorism and security training program in the spring of 2002, which almost every major trucking company in the United States is now mandating for their drivers, Willard said.

The course teaches drivers how to keep themselves safe by always keeping their trucks locked, and not keeping the vehicles running when they're not in them. It also provides various emergency contact and tipline numbers.

But it also tells people what kinds of activity to be on the alert for.

"Casing," for example, can include activities such as an individual inquiring about details, of hazardous material deliveries. There was one situation in Florida where a man was seen videotaping hazardous material dropoffs, Willard said.

"We talk to them about how a typical terrorist act is carried out," he added. "Terrorists typically don't wake up on Tuesday morning and blow something up on Tuesday afternoon. It normally goes through an extensive process of targeting, casing, etc… The first thing we do is make drivers aware of that process."

http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,236337,00.html

Pull_T
December 14, 2006, @ 12:55 PM
Same as the guys on the plane.

He patently acted like a guy who might be up to something so he could then cry "racial profiling, racial profiling!"


:yawn:

Adam_Schwartz
December 14, 2006, @ 12:57 PM
I am sure this guy is just a go-getter...he wanted to start moving haz mat cargo because he is a hard worker, that's all.

Always Dirty
December 14, 2006, @ 01:01 PM
Interrogate the shit out of him, then deport him. Next.

Pull_T
December 14, 2006, @ 01:07 PM
I'm just glad that another 9/11 was prevented due to the keen observation and swift action of the brave trucking instructor.

mambo#5
December 14, 2006, @ 01:10 PM
what makes me uncomfortable is having to read these news articles that basically are lecturing future terrorists about "WHAT NOT TO DO or HOW NOT TO ACT" in their next attempt.

Adam_Schwartz
December 14, 2006, @ 01:16 PM
In other words, he should have just done the entire course, then he could slam haz mat trucks into whatever he desired.

Always Dirty
December 14, 2006, @ 01:35 PM
I'm just glad that another 9/11 was prevented due to the keen observation and swift action of the brave trucking instructor.

What should they have done? Let it go? What's your problem with the chain of events that took place? Just curious...

mambo#5
December 14, 2006, @ 01:36 PM
In other words, he should have just done the entire course, then he could slam haz mat trucks into whatever he desired.

:huh: was that in reference to my comment? If it was, that's not my point. My point is this kind of investigation should be kept secret so that terrorists don't learn from the media how to avoid being detected the next time.

sakigt
December 14, 2006, @ 01:59 PM
what makes me uncomfortable is having to read these news articles that basically are lecturing future terrorists about "WHAT NOT TO DO or HOW NOT TO ACT" in their next attempt.

By that do you mean the obvious? :spit:

I mean, seriously. Are they sending the dumbest ones out to do their dirty work?

Pull_T
December 14, 2006, @ 02:40 PM
What should they have done? Let it go? What's your problem with the chain of events that took place? Just curious...

Oh I don't have an issue with them taking action...I just don't think the guy was going to be able to pull anything off, even if it wasn't an intentional ploy to get caught. i.e they didn;t save the world or anything.

Adam_Schwartz
December 14, 2006, @ 04:17 PM
:huh: was that in reference to my comment? If it was, that's not my point. My point is this kind of investigation should be kept secret so that terrorists don't learn from the media how to avoid being detected the next time.

I am sorry, I was just being facetious, not criticizing your comment. I totally understand your point - it's like all the "leaks" of classified info made to media outlets.

Adam_Schwartz
December 14, 2006, @ 04:19 PM
Oh I don't have an issue with them taking action...I just don't think the guy was going to be able to pull anything off, even if it wasn't an intentional ploy to get caught. i.e they didn;t save the world or anything.

If the US was smart, they would use Mohammed Abombinejad as an example, but since the US has been de-balled, that won't happen.

Always Dirty
December 14, 2006, @ 04:32 PM
Oh I don't have an issue with them taking action...I just don't think the guy was going to be able to pull anything off, even if it wasn't an intentional ploy to get caught. i.e they didn;t save the world or anything.

Got it - I think you and I share similar views regarding media sensationalism. :D

Wraab Wall
December 14, 2006, @ 04:59 PM
Wonder? Eff that! I wonder why it's not used more. Hell I'm on the do not fly list at airports. :lol: :wtf:

Adam_Schwartz
December 14, 2006, @ 06:07 PM
Wonder? Eff that! I wonder why it's not used more. Hell I'm on the do not fly list at airports. :lol: :wtf:

Sadly, there are those who think profiling is "horrible" and "insensitive", but obviously it's necessary.

Pull_T
December 14, 2006, @ 07:31 PM
Poly...the only problem is this had nothing to do with racial profiling...


But i have no problem with racial profiling...assuming it's effective. I'm liberal as hell when things are done to/against someone for no cause but I am willing to bend quite a bit if you can show it keeps planes from falling out of the sky.

Adam_Schwartz
December 14, 2006, @ 10:33 PM
I know THIS particular incident had nothing to do with racial profiling, at least directly, but it DOES re-enforce the fact that we need to utilize racial profiling, particularly for people of Middle Eastern descent who act suspiciously. When the Irish declare jihad on the West, then we can profile them. That was what I was implying.

Killer
December 14, 2006, @ 10:47 PM
I know THIS particular incident had nothing to do with racial profiling, at least directly, but it DOES re-enforce the fact that we need to utilize racial profiling, particularly for people of Middle Eastern descent who act suspiciously. When the Irish declare jihad on the West, then we can profile them. That was what I was implying.:werd:

Adam_Schwartz
December 14, 2006, @ 10:51 PM
Can you imagine the Irish delcaring jihad on the entire Western civilization? Not sure there is enough Killians in the world for that to happen.

Pull_T
December 14, 2006, @ 11:31 PM
Can you imagine the Irish delcaring jihad on the entire Western civilization? Not sure there is enough Killians in the world for that to happen.

http://i60.photobucket.com/albums/h3/JSill69/BoondockSaints.jpg

Adam_Schwartz
January 10, 2007, @ 02:22 PM
Update about the guy who just wanted to learn to drive hazmat trucks forward:


By Karen Lee ZinerJournal Staff Writer

Antiterrorism officials have widened their investigation of Mohammed Yousuf Mullawala, a 28-year-old Indian national arrested last month after his behavior drew attention at a Smithfield tractor-trailer school. Authorities say Mullawala’s “problematic” cell-phone records and his apparent guise as an international student prompted the now-national probe.

“We’ve tied some of his cell-phone records to people of interest nationally” whose behavior points to “terrorist indicators,” said state police Maj. Steven O’Donnell. “They’re not your typical person’s cell-phone history … the volume of contacts obviously raises the level of suspicion.”

“We don’t know whether he’s a major player, a minor player, or any type of player” in the world of terrorism. “But the indicators lead us to believe that his behavior is not normal,” O’Donnell said.

“We are working with wherever the phone numbers take us, and to whatever cities,” said O’Donnell. That includes New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, Rhode Island, and elsewhere in the country. “We are interviewing everybody and anybody that may have a relation to him.”

Investigators are still studying Mullawala’s laptop computer for possible leads, and following his paper trail.

Mullawala’s interest in purchasing software on hazardous materials and his lack of interest in learning to back up a rig drew the attention of the trucking-school owners, and eventually, the federal Department of Homeland Security.

Mullawala has been held at the Suffolk County Detention Center in Boston since Dec. 5, on a civil immigration charge of violating his student visa.

The investigation now involves the Rhode Island State Police Fusion Center (a conglomerate of law enforcement overseen by state police) and reciprocal fusion centers in other states; the FBI’s Joint Anti-Terrorism Task Force and the federal Office of Immigration and Customs Enforcement.

“He’s being cooperative, in the sense that he’s talking to us and responding to our questions” while he awaits his immigration hearing, O’Donnell said. “Whether his responses are accurate across the board is another question.”

Mullawala faces an immigration hearing at which time “we will ask that he be deported,” said O’Donnell.

A warrant was also issued for his arrest on a criminal charge of identity theft, alleging that Mullawala falsely said he was a Rhode Island resident in order to obtain a driver’s license here, O’Donnell said. The warrant was issued after Mullawala’s detention in Boston. The warrant has not been served “because he was already in prison,” said O’Donnell. Regardless, Mullawala’s case is a criminal investigation.

O’Donnell cited a totality of circumstances that put “a homing beacon” on Mullawala and led to the national investigation.

Besides the phone records, they include his enrollment in three separate colleges; his multiple addresses — only some of which he may have lived at — and his movements between Rhode Island, Connecticut, New York and New Jersey and coinciding succession of licenses in a three-or four-year period. All of these factors were discovered after his arrest.

The seven addresses include locations in Connecticut, Rhode Island, the Bronx, Queens and Long Island.

“We’re clear that he was here under the guise of being a student. He was not a student,” O’Donnell said. “Whatever his motives were, he applied to be a student, left school, went to another school, he left school. Not only did he sign up, but never went to school.”

Mullawala signed up for computer technology and/or English immersion classes at Johnson & Wales University in Rhode Island, the University of Bridgeport in Connecticut, and the City University of New York, but apparently attended either briefly or not at all, according to school administrators and law enforcement authorities.

“He got accepted, signed up, and moved on,” said O’Donnell. The first time may not have signaled anything unusual, “but a second time, third time, that doesn’t make sense.”

The succession of driver’s licenses and addresses are also questionable, O’Donnell said, “but the coup de grâce is the truck driver’s school. It’s so blatantly obvious. Even a novice — a person who has no knowledge of terrorist activity — would think this is strange behavior.”

Strange, O’Donnell said, in that Mullawala attended a 30-day school and left after the second day; was not especially concerned about learning how to back up a rig, and sought a commercial driver’s license that would allow him to transport hazardous materials.

The school’s owners told The Journal last month that Mullawala also came to class wearing business clothes and asked fellow students about the process for gaining FBI clearance for the HAZMAT license. He was also an inept driver, according to instructor Ed Mowry.

After Mullawala’s arrest, investigators seized a passport at one of seven addresses tied to Mullawala.

According to the passport, Mullawala is from Cotpally, India. He first entered this country on Sept 9, 2002.

“He was recruited overseas by a Johnson & Wales employee to come to this country to be a student,” said O’Donnell.

J&W spokeswoman Miriam Weinstein said Mullawala was enrolled in the School of Technology in fall 2002 through spring 2003; whether he actually attended classes was unclear. He gave an address of 181 Carpenter St., just a few blocks from the Providence Public Safety Complex, but investigators do not believe he ever lived there.

“He said he heard about the [Smithfield] tractor-trailer school while he was at Johnson & Wales,” O’Donnell said, and signed up for classes “because there was no waiting list, and the requirements to get a commercial driver’s license are less than New York.”

Last November, according to O’Donnell, Mullawala worked for a New York taxi-limousine service called NYC 2 WAY; another violation of his student visa. There he received W-2 forms, “and we’re looking into that with the IRS,” O’Donnell added.

Investigators are also knocking on doors.

Deborah Bashar of Shelton, Conn., recalled a recent visit by an FBI Joint Terrorism Task Force agent out of New Haven, who showed her a photo of Mullawala and said he was wanted “for questioning.”

“I didn’t know his name. I saw his picture and recognized him from the picture,” she said in a phone interview last week.

Bashar said she and her fiancé, Frank Perry, first encountered the man they recognized from the photo when they were on a walk-through of the house in Connecticut they bought in 2003. Mullawala was living in a first-floor apartment that she believes he shared with four or five other people.

Asked how she was sure she knew the man in the photograph, Bashar said, “He was very strange. Just really weird. When we came to look at the house, he was just sitting in the room in the middle of the bed, cross-legged. I thought he was just sitting there. Frank said there was a TV on — there was like a blue screen. He was staring at a blank TV, and the picture was all blue.”

Authorities say Mullawala is a Muslim: asked if could have been praying, Bashar said, “It almost kind of looked like that,” except for the strangeness of the blank blue screen.

Mullawala did not say anything at that time, Bashar said.

But after she and Perry purchased the house, “we walked in the front door and he was standing in the living room. I was like, ‘What are you doing here? You’re not supposed to be here anymore.’ ”

“He just said he was getting some of his stuff, and I was like, ‘All of your stuff should have been out.’ He picked up his stuff … some bags or boxes … and walked out the door.” Since the FBI came to visit, Bashar has learned more about Mullawala and his arrest.

“I was like, ‘Oh my god.’ So it’s all kind of weird to me. Kind of scary, actually.”

Investigators have also checked into Mullawala’s brief work history at NYC 2 Way, whose limousine fleet primarily operates in the Tri-State (New York, New Jersey and Connecticut) area.

Driver relations manager Jeffrey Kong said in a phone interview that Mullawala worked for NYC 2 Way for one month, starting in early November of last year. His last paycheck was dated Dec. 3.

Like all of the 1,500 drivers, Mullawala was an independent contractor. He provided a driver’s license, from New Jersey, and a temporary license issued last March by the New York City Taxi and Limousine Commission. He provided a cell phone number with a 401 area code. Mullawala grossed a little more than $3,300, for 82 trips.

He also apparently used the Lincoln Town Car he leased from NYC 2 WAY to drive to the Nationwide Tractor-Trailer School in Smithfield.

Kong said, “The detective [from Rhode Island] told me to pick up the car, because the car did belong to the company.” To avoid garage fees, “I hurried and arranged someone to pick up the car.”

http://www.projo.com/news/content/DRIVER_PROBE9_01-09-07_AG3PUO3.2f614be.html

mambo#5
January 10, 2007, @ 03:35 PM
that guys sucks at being a terrorist...... thank God.

Caliadria
January 11, 2007, @ 06:37 PM
Wow, I'll say. I love the airhead woman who describes meeting him at her house. " 'I was like, 'oh my god,'" :rofl: